All right, here it goes...
Some of you may know (in fact all of you. Only my friends actually read this thing, I'm sure) that I was really excited for Sucker Punch. This movie looked AWESOME. I mean, check out this trailer and tell me that this doesn't look like it's going to be the coolest movie you've ever seen.
The above video encompasses basically every daydream I've ever had. This is almost literally how I see things in my head! (Same thing I thought when I saw Scott Pilgrim, btw). But anyway, that's not the point. The point is: I was really excited for this movie.
I really wasn't hoping for much. An entertaining night at the movies with some strong female characters and awesome fight scenes. I've got to be honest, that's what I got when I went to see Sucker Punch. But, man, that movie was not good. It wasn't bad, but it was most certainly not good.
I was a little confused from the beginning of the movie. The opening scene shows Baby Doll's mother dying, leaving everything she owns to her two daughters. Baby Doll's father isn't too pleased, and gets all drunk and stuff. Long story short, Baby Doll shoots at her father, but misses and kills her sister instead. Daddy sends Baby Doll to the crazy house, which is where our adventure will take place (well.. kind of).
Baby Doll meets 4 other girls, including a black-haired girl named Blondie, an asian girl names Amber (a little racist? naw) and two sisters named Rocket and Sweet Pea. Rocket, Sweet Pea and Baby Doll are really the only important characters in terms of plot, but the others are cool too.
Blue is the name of the guy who takes care of them in the mental institution. This is all the exposition you really need to know.
The girls go on quests (like in an RPG) in their imaginary world and recover artifacts that they need to escape. In the end, turns out that all of the main five characters except for Sweet Pea and Baby Doll were imaginary, and Sweet Pea eventually escapes, and Baby Doll is left in the asylum. (She wasn't insane before, but now she is. That actually did used to happen, and that's actually something I would have liked to have seen more of. Baby Doll's transition into insanity). I did mention there were gonna be spoilers. right?
Here's why I didn't like the plot. The whole deal is that Baby Doll imagines herself and the other characters in a brothel. Which is fair, because Blue exploits the women. The whole movie basically takes place in this brothel, causing you to be confused/not care about what's really going on. Zack Snyder's trying to go all Inception on you, and ultimately fails. When the dancing instructor (the therapist in real life) puts on music, Baby Doll goes into a further "dream state" where she fights monsters and stuff. basically, a video game. These moments are the only cool parts of the movie. Seriously, if this movie were just the fight scenes and the soundtrack, I would be just as happy, if not more.
/END OF LAME STORY CRAP/
So, the feeling I got from the movie is that Zack Snyder made a few fight scenes, and thought "I want to show people these, but there's no context for them." I'm having trouble explaining this, so I'm just gonna show you guys a conversation I had with a good friend of mine, Joelle over Facebook. She's a girl, so I really wanted to get her perspective on the film. We were both excited to see strong female leads. Anyway, here is a peek into the grand social like of Zach!
Joelle: "I can't rate it, there are too many aspects to consider. The whole idea of the different realities/dreams/imaginary worlds was awesome, but the rest of it sort of lacked. I don't know... if I have to choose, maybe a 5 or 6." (5 is average, btw).
Me: "Fair enough. The feeling I get is that it was a really awesome idea, and they could have done a lot with it. But it wasn't completely clear what Zack Snyder wanted me to think. What message was this movie trying to portray? To me, he wasn't JUST trying to give us a fun time, he wanted to tell us something. Perhaps about the mistreatment of women by authority? Funny way of doing that, what with all of those camera shots from under the characters skirts'. I'm still not completely sure what to think.
Joelle: "That's exactly what I got from that, too. You could get a different message by looking at each scene from a different perspective, but none of those messages fit in every part of the movie. It's almost as if someone told Zack Snyder that he needed to show that girls are awesome too, so he threw in some female fighting, but wanted to get the male audience to come, so put the girls in fishnet stockings.
Me: "Okay, I can get that. But maybe he was trying to do too much, and two completely different things, for that matter. Like you said, to appeal to the female AND the male audience. It didn't work for me. (I'm not both genders, but I'd like to think I'm in-tune with this sort of thing. :P). And the whole concept of the movie lead me to believe it was just gonna be a fun time, but instead they tried (key word-tried) to give a deep plot. I think a lot of things Snyder was trying to do got lost in translation."
Joelle: "I don't even know how to reply to that, because that's the perfect way to explain it." You're so smart and you have really big muscles.
I think that this movie had acknowledged that it was basically a video game, then they could have had a lot of fun with it, and the audience would have had fun, too. I think this movie took itself too seriously. Like I said, Snyder wanted to have a really fun action movie, but he also wanted to have a complicated plot and a deep message. This movie could have just been a fun action movie with a message about self-empowerment, and it would have been a lot of fun. This move could have been like Scott Pilgrim vs. The World if it had simply acknowledged that it was silly. The audience all understood that it was silly, but I can't be sure if the director did.
Anyway, I was disappointed with this movie. I wanted it to be a cult-classic, and it could have been. Should you watch it? That's a great question, inquisitive reader. I'd say that if you want to have a fun time at the movies with your friend, or a lady or whatever... then yeah, sure. It was not worth seeing opening night, though. If you're looking for an Oscar movie, you're out of luck. I'd suggest going to see it with some friends, and deciding for yourself.
PS: (For those who have seen the movie): Would this movie not have been totally awesome as an anime movie? I mean, anime can get away with stupid stuff like this. It could have worked!
TL;DR (a segment done by my friend, zorkonlikespie)
Today, I had a nap. When I woke up, I had birthday cake. True story.